The case was a typical civil-criminal cross case with close link with another criminal case and highly identical factual circumstances. After accepting the instruction of the subsidiary of the Chinese central enterprise, we analyzed the legal relations and facts involved and found that the claim should not fall into the scope of civil cases from such perspectives as nature, rule of imputation, responsibility constitutive conditions and the applicable legal provisions. After trials which lasted two years, both the court of first instance and the court of second instance eventually adopted our defense opinions and ruled to dismiss the plaintiff’s claim.
Follow: